To Thomas Jefferson
Philada. April 16th. 1781
The inclosed paper is a copy of a report from a Committee, now lying on
the table of Congress for Consideration. The delicacy and importance of the
subject makes me wish for your judgment on it before it undergoes the final
decision of Congress.
The necessity of arming Congress with coercive powers arises from the
shameful deficiency of some of the States, which are most capable of yielding
their apportioned supplies, and the military exactions to which others already
exhausted by the enemy, and our own troops are in consequence exposed. Without
such powers too in the general government, the whole confederacy may be
insulted and the most salutary measures frustrated by the most inconsiderable
State in the Union. At a time when all the other States were submitting to the
loss and inconveniency of an embargo on their exports, Delaware absolutely
declined coming into the measure, and not only defeated the general object of
it, but enriched herself at the expence of those who did their duty.
The expediency, however, of making the proposed application to the
States will depend on the probability of their complying with it. If they
should refuse, Congress will be in a worse situation than at present: for as
the confederation now stands, and according to the nature even of alliances
much less intimate, there is an implied right of coercion against the
delinquent party, and the exercise of it by Congress whenever a palpable
necessity occurs will probably be acquiesced in.
It may be asked perhaps by what means Congress could exercise such a
power if the States were to invest them with it? As long as there is a regular
army on foot a small detachment from it, acting under Civil authority, would at
any time render a voluntary contribution of supplies due from a State, an
eligible alternative. But there is a still more easy and efficacious mode. The
situation of most of the States is such, that two or three vessels of force
employed against their trade will make it their interest to yield prompt
obidience to all just requisitions on them. With respect to those States that
have little or no foreign trade of their own it is provided that all inland
trade with such states as supply them with foreign merchandize may be
interdicted and the concurrence of the latter may be enforced in case of
refusal by operations on their foreign trade.
There is a collateral reason which interests the States who are feeble
in maritime resources, in such a plan. If a naval armament was considered as
the proper instrument of general Government, it would be both preserved in a
respectable State in time of peace, and it would be an object to mann it with
Citizens taken in due proportions from every State. A Navy so formed and under
the orders of the general Council of the States, would not only be a guard
against aggression & insults from abroad; but without it what is to protect
the Southern States for many years to come against the insults &
aggressions of their N. Brethren.
I am Dear Sir Yr. sincere friend & obt. servt.