Constitution and gavel

Trial Jury Reform

The jury system was made part of our Constitution because the Founders did not trust judges, but ever since the Constitution was adopted, there has been a struggle between judges and juries, with judges trying to confine juries to deciding the "facts" in a case, leaving the judges to decide the "law". In most criminal cases today, the constitutional and legal issues are not argued in the presence of the jury, and the jury does not get to read the legal briefs filed in the case. Judges try to intimidate juries into following their instructions, which are only advisory, and prosecute attorneys for contempt if they try to inform jurors of their right and power to decide the law as well as the "facts" in the case. In response, reformers are working to make sure jurors know their duty.

It is important to keep in mind that many cases involve legal issues that neither the judge nor any of the lawyers have encountered previously. The trial is then a learning experience for all involved, including the jury. If the judge needs to hear the legal arguments to learn enough to decide motions, then the jury needs to hear those same arguments to decide the verdict.

Click on the button to get the indicated file format:
Format HTML Text WP PDF RTF Word Image
Local HTML Version or Menu Text Version Zipped WordPerfect Version PDF Version RTF Version MS Word Version Image
Remote Remote Link - HTML Remote Link - Text Remote Link - Wordperfect Remote Link - PDF Remote Link - RTF Remote Link - Word Remote Link - Image

Leading Court Cases


State Constitutional Reform


Trial Jury Reform Groups


Trial Jury Discussion Forums

  1. FIJA. To [un]subscribe, send message to FIJA-subscribe@yahoogroups.com. — Discussion of fully informed jury issues.

Jury Instruction Reform — California

The California Judicial Council Task Force on Jury Instructions has been charged by Chief Justice Ronald George with writing "jury instructions that both accurately state the law and are more easily understandable to jurors." Here are their draft proposals and our comments:


Recommended Reading

Media coverage


Search trial jury history and reform

Loading
Home » Jurisdiction and Due Process » Jury Reform
Original URL: http://www.constitution.org/jury/pj/pj-us.htm
Maintained: Jon Roland of the Constitution Society
Original date: 1996/04/20 —