Up next in 10
Reform of How American History is Taught 2010/01/25 (05)
24 views
Jun 5, 2025
Jon Roland explains how state teaching of American History is failing our students and needs to be reformed. With Lela Pittenger. Austin Constitution Meetup Jan. 25, 2010.
View Video Transcript
0:00
you know we've historically had for
0:02
example citizens review commissions
0:04
to review police
0:07
we have one here in austin
0:10
in my view it
0:12
does not really do the job that it
0:14
should it's too captured by the police
0:20
you need something more like a grand
0:22
jury
0:24
which
0:26
sits for limited periods of time
0:28
and can't be captured by the subject
0:31
that is supposed to be supervising
0:34
so
0:36
these commissions need to serve for
0:39
short periods of time
0:41
be randomly selected so that they're
0:44
they can't be captured by the
0:46
by the interests that they're trying to
0:49
supervise
0:50
and then that made me think of one more
0:52
question
0:54
let's say
0:55
you pull your your 23 out of this pool
0:58
of 230. once those 23 have served do you
1:02
take them out of the pool
1:04
and finish through all the rest rotate
1:07
through all the rest or do you put them
1:08
back in after their service and take the
1:10
chance that they could be chosen a
1:12
second time
1:13
well
1:14
that's a detail to be worked out what i
1:16
would suggest is that they be put back
1:19
in the pool after say
1:21
two years or three years or something
1:23
like that right
1:24
uh the way the people are put back in
1:26
the jury pool
1:28
for trial juries
1:30
uh that way there's a chance they could
1:32
be recalled again
1:34
but you're not overburdening them with
1:36
having to serve too often or for too
1:38
long
1:40
that's it for right now until you give
1:41
me some more details on what you have
1:43
prepared
1:44
okay well let's uh
1:46
discuss
1:48
some of the
1:50
dynamics that i would hope to emerge
1:53
from office
1:57
there's a real need of course you and i
1:59
have worked on
2:01
the state board of education trying to
2:03
reform things there
2:05
and we
2:06
perhaps ought to discuss that a little
2:09
bit
2:10
you testified i testified
2:13
i found that
2:16
there is no
2:20
course
2:21
in american history
2:23
uh
2:24
up to 1877
2:27
beyond grade 8.
2:29
it's taught in grade 8 and not again
2:33
there's a course in american history
2:35
from 1877
2:38
to the present
2:40
taught in grade 11
2:44
but
2:45
there's a three-year get
2:49
and in my view that's won't work
2:53
uh kids at
2:55
grade 11 i mean in grade 8
2:58
are not mature enough to assimilate
3:00
american history from that period now it
3:04
doesn't hurt to present it to them
3:06
but they should get it again in grade
3:08
11.
3:10
when i went to public school
3:13
back in the
3:15
50s and up to 1962
3:19
we had world history
3:21
in grade 10
3:23
american history all the way from the
3:25
beginning to the end
3:27
in grade 11
3:28
and american government
3:31
in grade 12.
3:34
now that worked pretty well
3:37
uh
3:38
kids
3:39
were beginning to become mature enough
3:42
in grade 10
3:44
at least enough for world history
3:47
and by grade 11 and 12 they were ready
3:50
for american history and government
3:55
the most important period in american
3:57
history
3:59
is the period before 1877 right
4:03
now that's when they can expect to learn
4:06
most of what they'll need for american
4:09
government which under the current
4:11
scheme is taught in grade 11.
4:15
you cannot really teach american
4:17
government if you also don't teach
4:19
american history before 1877.
4:23
they want to understand it
4:26
so american
4:29
the texas education system
4:32
has gotten messed up
4:35
i have urged
4:37
the creation
4:38
i wrote the takes for
4:41
a grade 11
4:42
american history
4:44
through up to 1877
4:47
proposed it to the board
4:49
and i'm now trying to rally
4:51
support among my friends and neighbors
4:54
to put pressure on the board to adopt it
4:58
they have a chance to do that in march
5:01
so if you know of anyone
5:03
that you can mobilize to
5:06
join in this effort
5:08
please do so is not too late
5:12
they have the proposal before them
5:14
they meet in march and there's no reason
5:16
why they can't adopt it at that time but
5:19
when you say get involved what should
5:21
people do do they need to call a
5:22
particular person do they need to send
5:24
letters what should they do
5:26
well first of all of course they should
5:28
contact their own member of the state
5:30
board of education do you know where
5:31
people can find that
5:33
that's available online
5:36
it's a
5:38
just
5:39
do a web search on texas board of
5:42
education
5:43
you can find it all there
5:45
uh you can you'll find in particular the
5:47
phone numbers
5:49
you can call and ask who is your member
5:52
uh and eventually you can figure it out
5:56
but then you also need to
5:58
contact your friends and neighbors
6:00
to urge them
6:02
to join in the effort
6:04
one voice is not enough you need to get
6:06
uh
6:08
20 30 40 people
6:10
on each member of the board
6:13
and if each member of the board got 20
6:15
30 40 people
6:17
uh that could make the enough
6:21
to get them to adopt it
6:24
especially since
6:25
a lot of the members of the board
6:27
already seemed receptive to the idea
6:29
when i presented it
6:31
at least based on the looks on their
6:32
faces
6:34
i didn't get any questions
6:36
i was hoping for questions
6:39
but usually they ask me questions
6:41
by this time i think they're beginning
6:43
to get kind of used to me
6:46
but uh it is a
6:49
time for everybody who views this view
6:51
video
6:53
to get active
6:54
you don't have much time
6:56
and
6:57
keep in mind that you're not just doing
6:59
this for texas
7:01
because if texas adopts
7:04
uh
7:05
american history
7:06
up to 1877
7:08
for grade 11
7:10
it's going to dictate the textbooks for
7:13
the
7:13
entire country
7:16
so you're not just doing it for texas
7:17
you're doing it for the united states
7:20
because i found in researching it that
7:23
most other states are also not teaching
7:26
american history
7:28
in grade 11 or 10 or 11 or 12 they're
7:31
teaching it only after grade 8.
7:34
so this is a nationwide problem
7:38
and we can fix it here in texas
7:41
it'll take a few years for the
7:43
change to propagate
7:45
but we can make a huge difference
7:48
if we get on the ball
7:50
so uh
7:52
all you folks listening to this video
7:55
watching this video
7:57
uh it's the vowels in your court we need
8:00
your help so get on with it
8:04
great what else should we talk about for
8:06
state board of education
8:08
well there's i also modified it teeths
8:11
for
8:12
american government
8:14
to strengthen it
8:16
it needed a lot of strengthening
8:20
there was a review panel which did some
8:22
strengthening
8:25
but not enough from my viewpoint
8:28
um
8:31
too many people have been going to the
8:33
state board saying they want
8:35
you know this or that or the other
8:38
the reality is that the only testimony
8:41
that seems to do any good
8:43
is when people actually come in and make
8:46
changes
8:47
propose changes to the tease
#Political Science
#Primary & Secondary Schooling (K-12)
#Public Policy