Clive Doyle reading the names of the fallen
23 views
Jun 5, 2025
Those who died during the assault on Mount Carmel, April 19, 1993.
View Video Transcript
0:06
February 28th
0:13
1993 the dust cleared two a half hours after the BF throw
0:21
in we had six of our people we
0:28
had four or five wound the ATF had four dead 20
0:38
two from what I understand those that died that day in
0:44
the first initial shooting for Winston Blake 28 years old from England
1:00
Winston was shot sitting in his room behind the water tanks at the back of the building when the helicopter shut up
1:08
our water supply he just Happ to be behind the water tanks and was
1:15
killed Peter J 24 years old from
1:21
Australia Peter was the one on top of the water town that I talked about
1:27
earlier Peter hipsman 28 from the United States initially from
1:34
New York but we met him in in Hawaii Peter was
1:41
shot up here in what the government called the dog run I
1:46
don't know why they called a dog run I don't think a dog ever got in there but
1:51
uh the people that got into the building into the U gymnasium section I guess
2:00
Footsteps in this hallway up there and just
2:06
blindly spread bullets all around hoping to hit something which
2:11
they did hit Harry Jones 64 who was David's
2:22
father-in-law the shot at the front door standing behind David when they when the
2:28
raid first started
2:34
Michael schroer 29 he was from
2:39
Florida he wasn't out there Al M TR was working
2:46
downtown at a shop that we rented for fixing cars
2:51
and doing body work and stuff like that he and two other men Bob Kendry being
2:58
one of them and a guy from England were down there when they heard what was going
3:05
on because they tried to come up the Farm Road to mount and couldn't get
3:11
through the road block so they made a big detour went around the big circle and uh start
3:18
coming in from the diva Lake Area through the fields they were following the
3:25
creek my troa was out front and BoB Kendrick was bringing up
3:31
the rib because Bob was old had a hot condition and so
3:36
forth so the story we heard in the trial
3:42
was bhf had a whole bunch of snipers out
3:47
on the other property at the back of M conell in a bond they'd been there since 7:30 in the
3:55
morning which was like two hours before all the others
4:00
and at some point around 4:00 in the afternoon they were told to vacate their
4:07
position and to go back to the staging area
4:12
downtown so these guys I think forget how many have seven of them or
4:20
something a traing across the field two of them dressed as trees with
4:26
leaves and branches hanging on off somebody yelled out oh there's a guy in
4:32
the creek so they all hit the dirt and started
4:39
shooting they their story is that Mike shot a
4:45
f uh I don't know whether that was true or not one story I heard was that all that
4:52
might had was a a flare gun or something which isn't much good in a firefight
4:59
but anyway the government tell you that they shot KN and killed him down in the
5:07
creek the evidence shows that after that he uh somebody came up
5:14
and shotting twice in the back of the H while he's laying on the
5:20
ground execution stop to corroborate that story one of
5:27
the guys that was in jail with us said he's chasing he's coming up behind Mike
5:34
through the creek and when the shooting started he kind of hunk it down but he must have
5:40
made a noise you know amongst the branches trees and stuff somebody heard
5:46
him and they ordered him to come out so he came out with his arms up they told
5:51
him to get down on the ground and they handcuffed him and stuff to lead him away he says and I heard two more shots
6:00
this is a shooting so that kind of goes along with what the evidence
6:06
shows that mik was put out of his
6:13
misery they never retriev Mike's body for several
6:20
days one story is that they hung him on B fans but I don't know whether I buy
6:25
that but the excuse was they were too scared to go in there with a helicopter and retrieve each body because we might
6:32
shoot him from from this building here now you can't see the creek P from
6:40
this building the land you know goes downhill you couldn't even see the big
6:46
huge bond that our neighbor had on the property where they' been hold up all
6:53
day let alone anybody in the tree
6:59
J Wendell 34 even
7:06
know she was a white D she uh used to claim she was the only
7:13
real Hawaiian out of the whole bunch that came from Hawaii everybody else was from some you know some other state just
7:20
gone to live in Haw she would know that she's the one that was
7:26
shut in her bed upstairs second floor shortly
7:33
after combing the little girl's head a children's
7:40
head also on February 28th we had four agents like I
7:46
said cona blue Todd mcken Robert Willams and Steve
7:55
Willows it's possible that they were shot by people I don't know it's also
8:02
possible they might have been shot by their
8:07
own they're not going to admit it but some of the evidence seems to
8:13
indicate that one of two of them at least might have been shot by their own
8:21
people 50 days later we have the
8:28
fire said building is demolished within 12 some
8:36
minutes you know we had a fire right on this same spot back in 1983 10 years
8:44
before was a fire electrical fire with in the roof and uh we called the fire brigade
8:52
and they came out five different fire stations responded we had 11 vehicles
9:00
the building but to the ground in about five or six
9:08
hours started burning around 7:30 in the morning and last till 1 or so o00 1 or
9:14
2:00 in the afternoon this one burned in 12
9:21
minutes first one on the list Chanel and
9:32
most of us don't know Chanel Andra she was only one year
9:41
old her Aunt Jennifer Andra
9:46
19 and Jennifer's sister and Chanel's mother Katherine andr
9:53
24 these girls have come from California well Chanel was born at two sisters came
10:01
from California but they were of Argentinian nationality
10:08
originally Isaiah Barrios page four and Crystal
10:15
baral page three these were grandchildren of ailia
10:25
s Susan excuse me George Bennett 35 from
10:33
England Susan benter 31 from England Mary Jean Mor from the United
10:42
States she was a friend of aelas she Trudy
10:50
may had heard David speak up in Northern California all three of them accepted
10:58
and moved to Texas
11:04
Pablo C page 38 from
11:13
Israel Pablo was also originally from artina was a Jewish boy that David met
11:20
on one of his trips to Israel
11:27
and David gave him elri in Israel when he was
11:33
leaving sc one of the days you bring it back or
11:39
give it back or something but a few years L before he came
11:46
home abali Davies from
11:51
England abalo was from Nigeria originally but came to us from England
12:00
Cherry Doyle 18 Beverly
12:05
Elliot h30 from England she was the fiance of Winston
12:18
Blake she's also relative of Livingston
12:24
fi Doris Fagan Livingston's mother 51 from England
12:30
heent Fagan Livingston's wife 30 years old
12:37
from 32 years old from both of Livingston's children when
12:45
negotiated out during The Siege they live in England
12:52
today Lisa Marie Farris 24 United States from California
13:00
Raymond PR 76 he was a US citizen but he'd been
13:07
born in Canada originally Dal Jen 3 years
13:16
old PES jent one year
13:23
old Diana Henry 28 from England
13:30
Paulina Henry 24 from England Philip Henry 22 from
13:38
England Steven Henry 26 from
13:45
England Vanessa Henry 19 from England and Zilla Henry
13:52
55 a whole family from England most of these people not all of them but most of
13:58
these people from England of Jamaican descent they citizens of Eng some of
14:06
them BN any that their parents come from
14:12
Jama novet hipsman 36 from
14:19
Canada Floyd hman 61 he was from
14:26
Massachusetts Cyrus how 8 years old Rachel how
14:34
24 David's wife sty h 8 years
14:43
old Cherry Jew
14:50
43 from California in Hawaii sher's mother just died the
14:57
beginning of this year K Jewel who you may have heard
15:04
about years ago testifying and so forth about certain things that were
15:11
supposed to have happened krie just got married this
15:16
year and U I talked to on the phone the other day it was kind of
15:24
interesting marene had told us that she'd seen on Facebook
15:29
that uh K's grandmother had died so
15:36
she contacted us and I called my daughter Karen up in
15:43
Pennsylvania and uh Karen got on
15:49
Facebook and contacted cir and didn't actually talk and she sent her message
15:55
and said if she'd like to call me gave it my my phone
16:02
number I never heard anything from it for quite a while just couple of weeks
16:07
ago the phone rings and it's secur told she got
16:15
married there thinking of moving to Texas probably in the Austin
16:22
area so I called Karen after the phone call says guess who called me c called
16:32
got she says she did she hasn't talked to me since I contacted her on
16:41
Facebook give her a call here phone
16:56
number did I read St h
17:02
chica Jones two years old David Jones
17:11
38 Kathy Jones's
17:16
ex-husband little one Jones who was a twin to chica two years
17:22
old Serenity Jones four years old Bobby Lane who was a assistant to
17:30
the others two years
17:35
old David cares
17:41
33 Jeffrey little [Music]
17:46
32 Nicole little 24 from
17:52
Australia John Mark mcine 27 from England
17:59
Livingston malcol 26 from England Anita Martin
18:08
18 Diane Martin 41 no relation to CH
18:17
Martin Lisa Martin 13 Sheila Martin
18:23
15 Wayne M junor 20 and Wayne Lor
18:35
42 Abigail martinz
18:40
11 Audrey Martinez 13 Joseph Martinez eight these are
18:49
siblings of Isaiah and Crystal Dari
18:55
mention they are grandchildren of AIA
19:07
bernardet Melly 31 from England Sonia Murray 29 from
19:14
England Teresa Neer 48 from
19:21
England James riddle 32 from North Carolina
19:29
Rebecca sap 24 from New
19:37
Zealand Juliet santoo the mother of the Bario's children and the mara children
19:46
mention daughter of
19:53
AIA Judy Schneider 41
19:59
Schneider page two Steve Schneider
20:05
43 Clifford sers 33 from England Flor Cobi
20:13
34 she came to us from Hawaii but her
20:18
family all her on her side of the family from the
20:24
Philippines Scott sby 35 from Hawaii was a Japanese
20:33
descent Aisha Summers 17 from
20:38
Australia Gregory Summers 28 from the United States startle
20:46
Summers one Hollywood syvia one year
20:55
old the rain Sylvia 4 years old she was
21:00
an American citizen from Massachusetts but had been born in
21:05
England Rachel Sylvia her daughter age 12 Michelle Tibido
21:14
18 she's the mother of the
21:20
Twins and
21:29
serenity serenity okay Margaret Vega Margarita
21:36
Vega 47 she came to us from
21:42
Hawaii she uh was a Chinese descent Neil Vega
21:49
38 what's this New Zealand
21:55
Samoan that was born in the United States his parents came over on the boat I
22:02
think got here something Mark wend 40 years
22:09
old included in that list as those of you that have been here
22:14
before with two fetuses that were aborted during the F from Nicole and Aisha
22:29
I try to remember all the survivors that have passed on since 1993 and I only
22:35
came up 12 but I think it's maybe more than that so if I miss
22:55
anybody another
23:06
louder little louder conception Akuna was the mother of
23:12
ailia Jamie Castillo Jamie Caso was one of the guys that spent 15 years in the federal
23:23
prison he died of hepatitis shortly after he got released from
23:29
Edna Doyle my mother from Australia Tilly
23:37
FR wife of Raymond bnny
23:42
halderman Roy halderman victorine Hollingsworth of
23:48
England Wood Kendrick like I mentioned before was it Mal car when I first came
23:56
he died what was it
24:10
82 Ron and I got the chance to visit Bob and Jan Kendrick just last year when we
24:16
took a trip East I hope our visit didn't
24:26
Pace at least SE at that time he was still able still mobile able to drive
24:33
able to walk and all that sound like he went downhill pretty
24:39
fast James Lorden from North Carolina Catherine Madison originally
24:47
from RH Island became a branch when she when the family moved to
24:54
Arizona Trudy Maya
25:01
like I said Trudy Maya ailia and Mary Jane B all came from
25:10
North Carolina excuse me North California the last one was bladis opman
25:17
Canada bladis opman was Ruth Riddle's mother
25:33
that concludes the reading of the names basically
25:39
concludes our service as you can see over here we have
25:48
Refreshments food that's been brought by different ones mostly like she some of
25:54
other ladies
26:04
at the end at the end of the meal we will
26:10
uh leave it up to you to decide whether you want to go to
26:16
uh M whether you want to go to the museum or just what you want to do with
26:24
the rest of the afternoon but like I said if you want to go to the R Tor
26:29
Museum you need to let us know so we can contact
26:37
curator whatever he has to come from home to open up if you do any anybody that wants
26:45
to go to the museum after lunch contact R here in the middle you can get a list
26:51
and see if it's
27:03
[Applause] okay yes uh I'd like to say something
27:09
there's far few too few people here people now
27:15
why can't next year we all come back and bring a couple of people with us we cannot let this die on the vine okay
27:22
look what these people gave they gave their family they gave their lives that they
27:28
they they survive hell and all we have to do is come down here once a year and
27:34
in Comfort eat good food enjoy good Christian Fellowship can we make that
27:41
commitment if you're going to bring you're going to bring a busload Tomy give us a heads up so we can get a place
27:48
I have the paper to bu myself if I could feel it I would bring it well like I said hel Marie Taylor called yesterday
27:54
and she was kind of upset that we hadn't planned doing it over there
28:00
but the museum is plenty big enough but
28:06
uh or we can just make other arrangements the idea we need to know
28:12
bit a bit more than just yesterday to get it
28:17
together um I would love to see it back at M
28:24
car a lot of us if we could work something out the the current
28:31
resident what did you say what did you say I'm here I'm sorry yeah I'm sorry
28:38
too let's do it it's not me stopping it i' you've had an open invitation for 20
28:43
years okay well let's do it then well then let's do it let's just do it that's right I haven't been
28:52
stopping ites Hands Across the oce I'm stuck in the middle that's I've got
28:58
nothing against it being at Mount con except the fact we have two groups of
29:04
people I'll spr for the port two groups of people that come to
29:10
these memorials some like Mary different ones would love to
29:18
see it back out there but there are there have been people over the years that said if you
29:25
have it out there we won't be showing up we' tried to get over it get over it
29:32
they just show not a case of me getting over not trying to accommodate as many
29:37
people as possible what well if I could just suggest that if you took a poll
29:43
here with the people who have come this year these are the people you have these are the people that should influence the
29:49
decision of taking up this gentleman's this offer not the people that didn't come today right well they some of them
29:55
didn't come this year but I'm saying they have come in p and may come in the future I don't know if they don't
30:01
respond or if they've dropped out for lack of interest that said
30:09
look I would say the what what do the survivors I would
30:17
like to see it back myself
30:23
surv the only surv we got here areil and myself today
30:30
and and her